•  
  •  
 

Authors

Publication Date

11-15-2026

Abstract

Organ transplantation is one of modern medicine’s most extraordinary achievements. Yet, thousands of Americans die each year waiting for organs that could save their lives. The shortage is not a failure of science. It is a failure of law. While the United States operates a highly coordinated national framework for organ transplantation under federal law, organ donation remains governed by a patchwork of state law. Donation and transplantation are parts of a single, interdependent process, yet the law regulates them as separate systems. The resulting fragmentation undermines donor intent, creates confusion at the point of death, and perpetuates geographic inequities, ultimately limiting the supply of organs available for transplantation. Recent media scrutiny of the organ procurement process has made the problem more urgent: public skepticism has driven the largest decline in donor registrations in history, exposing just how fragile the current system is. This Note argues that the organ shortage is fundamentally a legal issue that is entirely within our capacity to change. It proposes a National Organ Donation Act that would replace the current patchwork of state laws with a unified national framework for organ donation, establishing irrevocable first-person authorization, a single national donor registry, and meaningful federal oversight. The result would be a system coherent enough to match the medicine it is meant to support, and robust enough for the Americans who will one day need it.

Share

COinS