•  
  •  
 

Publication Date

11-15-2026

Abstract

The current President is waging an all-out assault on the separation of powers. In pursuit of a totalizing vision of presidential power, he has sought to exercise prerogatives long understood to be within the purview of Congress. He has also moved to consolidate power within the executive branch, taking aim at every pocket of independent executive branch authority and rolling back post-Watergate reforms in law and practice. The Supreme Court has aided the President in many of these efforts by failing to act as a bulwark against—and in many instances affirmatively facilitating—an unprecedented expansion of presidential authority.

It is clear that many of these efforts to increase and consolidate presidential power have come at the expense of both Congress and independent agencies. Less understood, but equally important, is how this administration, and its muscular vision of executive authority, seeks to appropriate both the tools and, in some cases, the formal powers of the courts as well. Appreciating this new frontier of the separation of powers brings into focus an emerging approach to governance where law hardly matters, if it matters at all. By appropriating the powers of the courts, and by extracting settlements that reflect the President’s own mercurial views about the law, the President is constructing an entirely new legal system that upends existing accounts of how law operates. Whereas previously bargaining, settlement, and other forms of dispute resolution happened in the shadow of the law, novel presidential settlements now happen in the shadow of lawlessness. Law no longer supplies a constraint on how disputes are resolved; instead, the President demands, and parties accede to, assertions of extralegal presidential authority and control that are fundamentally incompatible with a system of rule by law.

This Article is the first to identify the emergence of a fundamentally new form of presidential power and control: the President’s power grab vis à-vis the courts. Presidential encroachments on the courts’ prerogatives include using litigation—particularly in the context of the President’s lawsuits against, and the resulting settlements with, media companies—as a tool of presidential control and presidential power. They also include the President’s efforts to create shadow legal processes that mirror the formal legal process but operate outside of it and under the President’s control. The President’s use of executive orders and other actions targeting prominent law firms and universities, and the resulting “settlements” and “deals” they have generated, are exemplary of this approach.

Over the past year, discussion of the relationship between the President and the courts has largely focused on the President’s attacks on and efforts to delegitimize the courts. But the phenomenon identified and discussed here reflects something different—not an attack on the courts but an effort to expropriate juridical authority for the President’s own ends. In this regard, the conventional separation of powers narrative in which the President and Congress are in conflict is no longer adequate to capture the shifting landscape of expanding executive authority. In his second term, President Trump has made unprecedented encroachments on the judiciary and its authority to “say what the law is.”

In this regard, we have moved beyond the traditional account of a unitary executive that embodies all executive branch authority. Instead, what is ascendant is an unprecedented account of executive authority that occupies and wields the powers of all three branches of government.

Share

COinS